Here’s a GMAT Quant question that transformed our teaching approach and might just change how you tackle absolute value questions forever:
If x is a positive number and |-4x + 8| ≥ 2, which of the following statements represents the exact range of x?
A. 3/2 ≤ x ≤ 5/2
B. 0 < x < 3/2 or x > 5/2
C. x ≤ 3/2 or x ≥ 5/2
D. 0 < x ≤ 3/2 or x ≥ 5/2
E. No solution
- The “Aha!” Moment
A student confidently declared: “Ma’am, why can’t we just split it at x = 2? When x is less than 2, the expression will be negative, and when x is greater than 2, it will be positive.”
I almost agreed… until something stopped me dead in my tracks.
Let’s test this logic with x = 1:
- When x = 1:
- -4(1) + 8 = 4
Wait… 4 is POSITIVE? But x = 1 is less than 2… shouldn’t this be negative?
- The Mind-Bending Revelation
Here’s what makes this problem fascinating: the negative coefficient (-4) completely flips our intuition upside down. Here’s why:
- As x increases, -4x becomes MORE negative
- Therefore, -4x + 8 actually DECREASES as x increases
- Traditional intuition = shattered
- Why Students Fall Into The Trap
Nearly 80% of my students pick Choice E (No solution). Here’s their typical thought process:
- “For x < 2: Expression must be negative” (Wrong!)
- “For x > 2: Expression must be positive” (Wrong again!)
- When they solve with these assumptions, they get contradictory results
- Conclusion: “No solution exists!”
- The GMAT’s Brilliant Twist
Here’s what makes this question genius:
With a positive coefficient (like |2x – 4|):
- As x increases → expression increases
- Split point cleanly divides negative/positive regions
But with a negative coefficient (like |-4x + 8|):
- As x increases → expression DECREASES
- Everything you thought you knew gets reversed!
- The Correct Solution Path
- Find the zero point: -4x + 8 = 0 → x = 2
- Critical realization: For x < 2, the expression is POSITIVE (not negative!)
- For x > 2, the expression is NEGATIVE (not positive!)
- Solve |-4x + 8| ≥ 2 algebraically
This leads us to: 0 < x ≤ 3/2 or x ≥ 5/2 (Choice D)
- TL;DR
When you see a negative coefficient in an absolute value inequality:
- Your “less than = negative, greater than = positive” instinct will betray you
- The expression DECREASES as x increases
- Don’t fall for the “No solution” trap – that’s exactly what the GMAT wants!
(Pro tip: Don’t let your instincts about positive/negative regions mislead you!)
Ready to apply this insight? Try this question: If x is positive and |-3x + 12| > 3, find the range of x.